Dental Therapy: Facts, Fiction and Fairytales

Dental Therapy - Facts, Fiction and Fairy Tales - Pinocchio

The Florida Dental Association (FDA) Has a Bad Truth-Ache.

The FDA is following organized dentistry’s national playbook in an attack using fiction and fairy tales to prevent Florida from expanding access to dental care. In spite of these well-funded untruths, 14 states have passed legislation to allow the licensing of dental therapists. Dental therapists are mid-level oral health providers who perform roughly 20% of the most common dental procedures – prevention, exams and fillings.  In this limited scope, dental therapists are educated and trained to the exact same level as dentists.

It’s very odd that the FDA is trying to block dental therapy legislation.

Dental therapists will work under supervision of dentists.

They are educated and trained in CODA-accredited programs – the same as dentists.

They even pass the EXACT SAME licensing exam as dentists for the procedures they perform.

Dental therapists have expanded access to care in 50 counties for over 100 years.

ALL published studies (nearly 1,500) show dental therapists provide safe, effective and quality care.

Dental Therapy - Facts, Fiction and Fairy Tales - Big Bad Wolf

Scare Tactics Used by Organized Dentistry

Scare Tactic #1: Whisper campaign.

The anti-dental therapy playbook recommends raising questions about safety in private meetings with legislators. Why? Because based on all the studies documenting safety, they know that can’t win that argument. Direct quote from the playbook: “… the issue [of safety] conjures images and draws emotional reactions.

Scare Tactic #2: Propaganda.

Organized dentistry likes to use scary language such as “irreversible surgical procedures” rather than fillings and “general anesthesia” instead of Novocain. Don’t fall for their scare tactics.

Scare Tactic #3: Misinformation and half-truths.

Organized dentistry likes to use faulty statistics to make it seem dental therapy isn’t living up to its promises. For example, in Minnesota an increase in 67, 532 more Minnesota children receiving dental care was presented as an actual “decline” in Medicaid utilization.

There’s overwhelming support – including dentists - for expanding dental access in Florida. The primary opposition is organized dentistry.

By the Numbers:
Why Dental Therapy Is Needed in Florida

0

Over 7.1 million Floridians lack access to basic dental care in their communities.

0

Over 1500 dentists are needed RIGHT NOW in 65 of Florida’s 67 counties. That number grows daily.

0

Florida is the fastest growing state in the nation. And we’re already the worst in the nation for number of people living in dental shortage areas.

0

Dental therapists have safely and effectively expanded access to dental care more than 100 years worldwide.

0

Dental therapy has been authorized in 14 states over the past 20 years.

Important Facts you Should Know

Organized dentistry such as the FDA are professional membership associations that represent the interests of their dues paying dentists. While they speak on behalf of their member dentists, they do not speak on behalf of ALL dentists in Florida, and certainly not for the millions of Florida citizens who can’t find affordable dental care in their communities. This is why the actions of the FDA are so appalling.  Hundreds of organizations and individuals throughout Florida are supportive of dental therapy as well. Since it would be a voluntary choice to hire dental therapists, and all research shows they expand dental access and provide safe, effective care, is it possible the FDA’s attempted anti-dental therapy smear campaign is more about protecting dentists’ wallets than the general public?

Organized dentistry likes to scare people into wondering whether dental therapists can handle a medical emergency. Medical emergencies are rare. However, dental therapists are trained to handle emergencies in the same manner as dentists. The current protocol for a dentist with a patient experiencing a medical emergency is to stop and call 911. Dental therapy education programs have the exact same accreditation standards as dentists for safety and emergency management. In addition, all the published research shows dental therapists have the education and training necessary to provide safe, high-quality care:

  • All dental therapy education programs are certified by the Commission on Dental Accreditation (CODA), the same as other dental schools.
  • Dental therapists must pass the EXACT SAME clinical licensure exam as dentists, limited to procedures within their scope of practice.
  • Dental therapists cannot operate outside of their scope of accreditation and are supervised by licensed dentists.

Organized dentistry likes to claim dental therapy will create a two-tiered system of oral health care in Florida – implying that poor Floridians and rural communities will receive a lower quality of dental care from dental therapists. This is patently false. The truth is a two-tiered system of care already exists — those who can afford dental care and those who can’t. All published studies (nearly 1,500) prove the care provided by dental therapists is safe and effective. Isn’t it galling that organized dentistry would seemingly prefer Floridians to go without basic dental care than to be treated by a dental therapist? Would the FDA like Floridians to continue relying on hospital emergency rooms – the most expensive care of all –  for pain pills and antibiotics because they can’t see a dentist in their community? Because that’s the reality for far too many Floridians.

Organized dentistry likes to point to their annual Mission of Mercy event as proof that they’re taking care of the dental care needs of Floridians who cannot afford dental care.  While dentists who participate in charity care events should be commended, charity care is episodic and often has long waiting lines for services. They also offer no dental home or opportunity for follow-up care. Most importantly, they only help a tiny fraction of Floridians each year. Over the last 9 years, only 13,850 Floridians have received dental care at a Mission of Mercy event. That’s roughly 1,500 individuals each year in a state with a population of over 23 million and over 7.1 million living in areas without access to basic dental care.

The FDA has historically favored solutions to improve dental access that sound good on paper, but they really don’t make a dent in helping everyday Floridians access dental care. For example, the dental student loan forgiveness program is only funded to help 10 dentists per year. Florida is the fastest growing state in the nation with 1,539 dentists needed RIGHT NOW to remove existing dentist shortages in nearly every Florida county. Annually, Florida’s dentist shortage grows at roughly the same rate as new dental students graduate from Florida dental schools. Couple this with the number of dentists who retire each year (Florida’s dentist population is much older than the national average) and it’s difficult to see Florida ever closing the dentist gap without workforce reform strategies that include dental therapy.

Resources